Book Reviews Policy

The book review editor, in consultation with the SSEC Board, has the right to revise or overrule any of the rules below when appropriate. Please send inquires to ssec@earlychina.org, addressing Maddalena Poli.

  1. The editor will set a deadline in consultation with the reviewer, and a word limit. As a general rule, we look for reviews around 1,500 words or longer, in consultation with the editor for book reviews. Review should summarize the author’s argument as well as engage with it, considering its contribution to the field. The book review editor will decide when the review is due, in consultation with the book review author. The book review editor has the option of not considering reviews received after the agreed-upon date, unless other agreements are reached between editor and reviewer. 
  2. EC does not publish responses to reviews. We encourage debate in the field, and invite authors to consider other publications if they wish to respond to a review. We do so to avoid producing a situation where the journal would become at times dominated by dialogues between authors and reviewers.
  3. We do not consider unsolicited book reviews. Authors and presses are invited to suggest books for review to ssec@earlychina.org, with subject line “Book Review Suggestion.” The book review editor will decide whether a particular book is appropriate for review in the journal. If necessary, this decision will be made in consultation with the editors of the journal. 
  4. AI usage in writing the review has to be disclosed in writing, in accordance with the EC AI Policy.  
  5. Please send your final review to ssec@earlychina.org. The editor, in consultation with the SSEC board if needed, has the final word on whether the publication should go forward. 
  6. The book review author shall receive no payment for completing a book review.